Writing for Kids: What Makes It Different from Writing for Adults?

by Pat Marcello

August 1997

 

So, you want to write for children?  You really like kids, and still have fond memories of books you read as a child.  And it's easier than writing books for adults, right?  Au contraire, mon ami!

 

The world of children's writing isn't as simple as talking animals or cute fairy tales.  In fact, before you write anything for children, you must first know your audience. Extreme differences exist between writing for pre-schoolers and writing for pre-teens.   Here is an idea of how different each age group can be:

 

Pre-school readers (to age 5):

 

Pre-schoolers are like brand new notebooks.  They are blank pages, waiting to be filled with information.  Anything that interests them, even the simplest things, are amazing to them.  You could write a 25 word story about a butterfly, a flower or a toy, and you might have a hit.

 

Yet with these early readers, adults do all the reading to the little ones.  They are the people who are choosing and buying these books, too.  These adults must not only like the books themselves,

but they must have evidence that their children like the books, too.

 

Children should be thrilled by what they hear, and will probably make noises or seemingly interminable comments, while the story is being read to them.  They will ask questions, and they will ask for that book to be read over and over and over and over again.

 

For this reason, pre-school materials should be kept simple, not only in content, but in style.  Sentences must be short, but even with books for the youngest children, the tone should never be

condescending.  Here is how "picture books" break down for each age group:

 

·         Baby books may have only one word to a page.  But this is a tough market.  Many of these are prepared in-house by the publishers themselves. 

 

·         Toddler books require short sentences.  Vocabulary should include words that two and three-year-olds can understand and repeat.

 

·         Four and five year olds want words they can pick out visually, allowing them to begin the process of learning to read. 

 

When writing picture books, sensory detail is highly important.  Make sure characters not only see and hear, but taste, smell and feel, as well.  Also, use words that can be dramatized by the reader, like snap, tweet, grrr, or crunch, for example. 

 

Younger children enjoy and remain interested in readers who use lots of expression.  Writers must give them something to express.  Read your stories aloud to see if they work well in the telling, and make sure they have a happy ending.

 

Colorful pictures that evoke emotions are also important to pre-schoolers.  If you have some artistic talent, you may eventually want to illustrate your own work. 

 

Yet, unless you are a professional artist, it's best not to submit illustrations with your manuscript.  Artists are normally hired by the publisher because they consider the illustrations in picture books so important.  In fact, there is a consensus among publishers of picture books that illustrations do half the work.

 

Therefore, the most important thing to keep in mind when writing is visualization.  Make sure that your material lends itself to drawings or pictures, and consider the format. 

 

The standard length is 32 pages, although it may be as short as 16 pages or as long as 64 pages, with word counts as low as 25 words or as high as 1,500.

 

To make sure your story fits, it is helpful to make a dummy copy.  This will help you to see if your story will work in words and pictures. 

 

A very detailed example of this is in Barbara Seuling's book "How to Write a Children's Book and Get It Published" and if you are interested in writing picture books, I encourage you to read it.

 

Another consideration when writing for this age group is their limited attention span.  A good rule of thumb for determining how long your story should be is to take the age of your intended

audience and then add one minute. 

 

For instance, if you have decided that your book is to be for four-year-old children, write a story that can be read aloud in five minutes. 

 

But don't think that all subjects will interest "pre-schoolers" in general.  The two-year-old may be interested in a story about a new bird flying into the backyard. 

 

Yet, the six-year-old needs a bit more, like a mystery story that is as simple as learning Mom's secret cookie ingredient.

 

Primary grade readers (approximately 6 through 8):

 

Children in the 6-8 year-old group have a variety of skills.  Some have already learned to read, some are learning and some still want to be read to.  Here is how the market breaks down for the primary graders:

 

Picture stories          

 

Although children in this age group still like picture books, they like them to be much longer.  These books are still being read to the children by adults, and twenty minutes is about the right length

of time for a story to be read aloud. 

 

The story should move with a fast-paced rhythm, and a lot of dialogue is good.  In fact, some editors like to see at least 50%. 

 

But although dialogue has gained greater importance, illustrations become less important because the story should be carried by the text. 

 

Known sometimes as "picture stories", these works should have plenty of action.  The sentence lengths can be longer, but short enough to be comfortable for reading aloud. 

 

Vocabulary should be simple enough to be understood by the child, but can be more difficult than they would be able to read themselves.

 

Easy Readers

 

Children in this age group have already begun to learn to read, and some of them will be moving into "Easy Readers (also known as Easy to Read or Young Readers)".   

 

Dr. Seuss' The Cat in the Hat is a prime example of this type of work.  Pictures are still important, but simpleness of the language is just as important.  A writer of easy readers must choose words that readers can sound out. 

 

Some larger words are okay, as long as the reader will be able to understand their meaning from the context of the sentence, or

they are explained before the word is presented. 

 

For instance, you might write: "The falcon's long claws at the end of his foot are called talons."

 

Primary-grade readers still like simple subjects, but love to garner basic facts from what they read, so they can tell their friends and family what they have learned. 

 

Yet, the plot must be simple and clear, but lively.  Humor, mystery and adventure are good bets, and they should be fun to read.

 

 Books about children who live in foreign countries, with tidbits about the culture interwoven, are perfect for easy readers.  For instance, let's say that Kaiko, your main character, lives in Japan. 

 

What does she eat when she comes to breakfast?  How long does she have to go to school each day?  These are details that readers in this age group can relate to. 

 

Children love to identify with the characters they are reading about, and always want to feel a bit older than they actually are.  Yet, characters should always be a bit older than your intended audience.  It's been said that kids read up, not down.

 

Still, keep sentences short (5to 6 words), but intersperse some longer sentences (not longer than 10 words each) to give your piece variety and greater readability.  

 

But don't talk down to these children, either.  They never want to be thought of as "babies" and language that is too simplistic will produce that effect.  The preferred length of an easy reader is 1,000 to 1, 500 words.

 

Chapter Books

 

Children of the 6-8 year old age group, who are a bit more advanced, may be enticed by Chapter Books.  These books are short, around 38 pages of text, and their plots remain simple. 

 

There is plenty of action and dialogue and short, short chapters.  A good example would be Sarah, Plain and Tall by Patricia MacLachlan.

 

If you are writing an Easy Reader, try not to break up phrases between lines.  Again, the best way to see if a child will be able to read your story comfortably is to read it aloud. 

 

And if you have access to children, no matter what age you age writing for, they are always the best judges of what works and what doesn't.

Middle-grade readers (approximately 9 to 12)

 

This age group is reading by themselves, almost entirely, and they are hungry for entertainment and for information.  They love to collect things, and they have begun to shift their focus from family to friends.

 

Characters should be older—12 to 13, and sentences should be 10 to 20 words long.  Middle-graders like plenty of action and quirky little facts, but hate too much description. 

 

Their interests rangefrom fantasy to novels with historical settings, but they still like adventure.   There are few illustrations, if any.  A length of 20,000 to 40,000 words is preferred.

 

This market has been very good for the past several years.  Evidence exists in the popularity of the Baby-sitters Club series by Ann M. Martin and the popular Goosebumps  series by R.L. Stine.  Yet, one of the best examples of quality middle-grade fiction is The Whipping Boy by Sid Fleischman.

Adolescents (pre-teens)

 

Don't call these kids "children" or you're in for trouble.  Adolescents want to be teenagers in the worst way, and they want to read stories with substance. 

 

In fact, they want to read about life, death and even age-appropriate sex , which is recognized, but never explicit.  Oh, and they love drama, but it has to be believable drama.

 

Although the mechanics of writing for adolescents isn't much different than writing for middle-graders, "Young Adult" fiction is more advanced in style and plot. 

 

Main characters should be junior high or high school age, and although no subject is off limits, good taste is still in order.

 

A good example of young adult writing is S.E. Hinton's The Outsiders.

Teenagers

 

Teenage readers are looking toward college or careers, but your audience will rarely exceed fifteen years of age.  Still, they want to read about life, and are trying to learn how to cope with it through

what they read. 

 

Dating, sex, jobs, college, getting an apartment and similar subjects will interest teen readers.  Suspense is popular, as is science-fiction and romance that is realistic and modern.

 

Yet, teen readers' abilities are widely different.  Some have difficulty reading, some have the same skills they had in the middle-grades, and some are more advanced.  

 

The best thing for writers of teenage material to do is to study the market they want to write for, and study the style and subject matter of  different publications that meet their interest.

 

Along with subject matter, tone is the most important criteria by which to gear teenage writing.   Never talk down to teenagers, either.  Many of them have already advanced to  adult material, but even if they haven't, they want to be considered "adults".

 

Hi-Lo Books

 

Hi-Lo books are for older readers (intermediate grades through high school) who need to improve their reading skills. 

 

So that they may remain interested in their reading material, Hi-Lo's (meaning high interest/low reading level), the subject matter will match that of texts for high school and beyond. 

 

You will find action, humor and romance with quick dialogue and plots that cover only one circumstance.  Yet, that problem should be realistic and contemporary.

 

The size and shape of a Hi-Lo book is that of a short novel.  It is often illustrated heavily, but with photographs, rather than drawings. 

 

Hi-Lo books are purchased mainly by schools.  They use a controlled vocabulary, and are 400 to 1,200 words in length.

 

Knowing your audience

 

You now know why writing for children is so different than writing for adults—the subject matter, style and format changes for each stage of the child's reading development.

 

But how do you figure out which type you want to write?  Read, read, read! Go to the library.  Take out several books in each segment of the market that interests you. 

 

When you find which type of children's literature enthralls you, you'll know what to do. 

 

Go back to the library, take out more picture books or easy readers or young adult novels and read them to really get a feel for what you're about to do.  After that, you still aren't quite ready.

 

Find children of the age group you want to write for and listen to them.  Watch how they move.  See what interests them.  Find out what makes them laugh. 

 

If you have children of your own at the level you want to write for, it's a start.  Yet, I encourage you to watch someone else's children, too.  Go to a park.  Ask a school if you might be able to sit-in on a class. 

 

Volunteer at the school cafeteria or in the playground.  Eat at McDonald's and get a laptop computer, so that you can write everything you see, hear, smell, taste and feel  (In lieu of that, a pen and paper will do). 

 

Some of my best stuff has been written in a fast-food restaurant.  Try it!  You might surprise yourself.

 

© Pat Marcello, 1997

 



Back to Write On! Home